Escapades Through British Literature
Follow on Twitter! (@dr_harrold)
  • Home
  • Armory
  • CP 12
    • Senior Speeches >
      • Pd 4 Speeches 2017
      • Pd 7 Speeches 2017
      • Pd 8 Speeches 2017
      • Pd 1 Speeches 2016
      • Pd 2 Speeches 2016
      • Pd 5 Speeches 2016
      • Pd 7 Speeches 2016
      • Pd 1 Speeches 2015
      • Pd 2 Speeches 2015
      • Pd 4 Speeches 2015
      • Pd 7 Speeches 2015
      • Pd 8 Speeches 2015
      • Pd 2 Speeches 2014
      • Pd 4 Speeches 2014
      • Pd 7 Speeches 2014
      • Pd 8 Speeches 2014
    • Unit 0: Digital Citizenship
    • Unit 1: Brave New World
    • Unit 2: Gods and Monsters
    • Unit 3: Twists and Tales
    • Unit 4: The Fountain and the Sword >
      • King Arthur Videos (2018)
      • King Arthur Videos (2017)
      • King Arthur Videos (2016)
      • King Arthur Group Projects (2015)
      • King Arthur Group Projects (2014)
      • King Arthur Readings
    • Unit 5: The Witch King
    • Unit 6: Journalists and Satirists
    • Unit 7: Research
    • Unit 8: Wilde's World
    • Legacy Pages >
      • Course Details
      • College Application Essay >
        • Biography Presentation
      • Beowulf >
        • Beowulf Introduction Webquest
        • Multi-Paragraph Essay
        • Beowulf Readings
      • The Canterbury Tales
      • King Arthur >
        • King Arthur Final Project
        • Indiana Jones Activity
      • The Hobbit >
        • Hobbit Readings
      • Renaissance Poetry
      • Macbeth >
        • Macbeth Readings
        • Macbeth Videos >
          • Act 1
          • Act 2
          • Act 3
          • Act 4
          • Act 5
        • Multi-Paragraph Essay
      • Research Project 12 >
        • Book Selections 2013
      • Restoration >
        • Satire
        • Web Tools
      • Romantic Period Poetry
      • Importance of Being Earnest
      • Senior Speech
  • Core 12
    • Be True to Your School
    • Beowulf
    • King Arthur
    • Catcher in the Rye >
      • Catcher in the Rye Readings
    • Values Paper
    • Macbeth
    • Short Stories >
      • Kaffir Boy
    • Research Project
    • And Then There Were None >
      • And Then There Were None Readings
    • Vocabulary 12
  • English 11
    • QUEST 1: Raisin in the Sun
    • QUEST 2: Catcher in the Rye
    • QUEST 3: Perks of Being a Wallflower
    • QUEST 4: The Great Gatsby
    • Quest 5: To Kill a Mockingbird >
      • Words of Wisdom
      • Mob Mentality LessonPaths
    • Quest 6: The Crucible
  • English 10
    • Course Details
    • War Horse
    • Night >
      • Night Readings
      • Multi-Paragraph Essay
      • Schindler's List Activity
      • Orpah Interview
      • Farewell To Manzanar
    • Short Readings
    • Satire Speech >
      • Good and Bad Speeches
    • Copper Sun >
      • Copper Sun Book
      • Socratic Seminars
    • Lesson Before Dying >
      • Lesson Before Dying Readings
    • Short Stories >
      • Harrison Bergeron
      • How Much Land Does a Man Need?
      • On The Rainy River
    • Poetry
    • Career Research
    • Lord of the Flies >
      • Lord of the Flies Readings
      • Lord of the Flies Paper
    • Research Project 10
    • Julius Caesar >
      • Julius Caesar Videos >
        • Act 1
        • Act 2
        • Act 3
        • Act 4
        • Act 5
      • Propaganda >
        • Dueling Speeches
        • Advertising
      • Julius Caesar Paper
      • Julius Caesar Readings
    • Antigone >
      • Antigone Readings
      • In-Class Essay
    • Vocabulary 10
    • Study Island
  • Contact Me
  • EBL
  • External Links
    • 3D Game Lab
    • Google Drive
    • Textbook
    • Gamification >
      • PETEC

Day 766: Teach to the Labels

2/4/2016

0 Comments

 
Yesterday, a group of nine or so English teachers were "locked" in a room and told to get started on drafting the curriculum for the upcoming school year. The day led to some valid discussion, some collaboration, some tedious labelling, and some disagreement, but overall it was a productive session. While there's still the proverbial "miles to go before we sleep", the new plans are off to a solid start. We have a clear consensus on the main texts, and now it's just a matter of selecting the activities and standards that go with them.

But as we were leaving, a small debate crept into the conversation: from where does the "teaching" come? The standards? The texts? The activities?

It's the age-old debate of "why do we teach Animal Farm?" or "why do we have to read Macbeth?" Every English teacher over the past dozen decades has likely had to address this issue at some point or another. While this complaint is usually the result of a bored student, it does lead to an interesting point: where does the content come from in an English class? I see two ways of approaching it: you can teach the content for it's own sake (because it's quality stuff everyone should be exposed to) and design activities to help absorb and understand the novels/stories/poems...or you can use the novel as lettuce. By this, I mean the novel isn't really important at all, but serves as a vehicle for delivering the actual flavor (the skills and tasks) to the students. In these cases, we might not care that students read and understand Macbeth, so much as we're caring that they read and understand anything. It's not that we want papers on Animal Farm, we just want papers because papers are the products of good writers. It's a worthy debate, and one which I go back and forth on all the time. There's lots of great books out there which, I would argue, need to be taught. On the other hand, it only takes a few moments to explain the plot of Beowulf. English should be about what you do after that.

But for some, the "stuff worth teaching" comes not from the novel or the activities at all...but from the standards themselves. And it is this that leads to an even deeper question: just what the heck are "standards". For those unfamiliar, PA (and all states) have lists and lists of standards which all students must be able to meet by certain grade levels. For English and Language Arts, there's several dozen standards which students must/should be able to master by 11th and 12th grade. Standards are often words as "students will..." or "students will be able to..." statements which delineate just what students will be able to do following class. It seems a really simple concept at first...but the more I thought about it yesterday, the more confused I got. Are these "standards" meant to be a divine source content...or are they simply labels for validating our activities or our novels? Are we supposed to read the standards and then design projects to appease them, or are we supposed to create activities and double-check them to make sure they're authorized content?

Some may not think the debate matters...and perhaps it doesn't. In many cases it's likely that the same conclusion will be reached no matter which direction they chose to approach it. But in some ways, I feel the answer is very important. As a teacher, I think there's still so some value in declaring activities, projects, tasks,and products valid in their own right. I don't come to work, nor do I lose sleep over whether or not students have demonstrated mastery over all the standards...but I'll be concerned if they can't write a paper, give a speech, construct their own research project, or craft a video. Teaching is about giving students the ability to do certain things...not just check off a list. The more I hear about the standards, the more I have to wonder whether it's our job to revalidate our tasks, our content, and our experiences. In the world, there won't be standards and labels anymore; you'll simply need to be able to do or do not. The quantification of content out of the novels and tasks and into the labels given The Labels the keys to the kingdom.

Picture
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    English Teacher | Instructional Technology Specialist | 2014-15 PBS Digital Innovator | Gamification Researcher | Marathon Runner | Ph.D RMU 2015

    Picture
    Picture
    Teach.com

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013

    Categories

    All

Content and Site Design by: Dr. Daniel Harrold
 Baldwin High School English Dept.

✕